“Be tender with her history!”  By

“Be tender with her history!”

“Be tender with her history,” the phrase rings in my ears on our final days of an extraordinary  film shoot penetrating the Russian heart of the Ural Mountains, a part of the world cut off from the west for most of the last century.  Over the last ten days, my Russian cousin Lena has emerged as the voice of my conscience, as I probe the tightly held secrets of my mother: a Nazi POW and one of millions forced into slavery for Hitler during the Second World War.


On the banks of River Chusovoya, which defined the purest, innocent  days of my mother’s childhood in Stalinist Russia, I am profoundly uneasy with the task I have set myself:  to piece together the mystery of a past that defined her as much as the magnificent river meandering beneath me.


And yet, I feel powerless to close Pandora’s Box. And rather obsessed to get the scenes I need to tell a story that has laid dormant for more than half a century.



Days earlier in Moscow, before flying to Perm,  I appeared on “RT”, the second largest television network in the world. As disingenuous as it seems, in front of potential audience of 25 million viewers of Russia Today, I grappled with an intimate debate with myself. Is there an expiry date on secrets taken to the grave?


IMG_0852Even before I boarded the plane to come to Russia, CBC Radio, posed the most troubling question of all: how could I defy my mother’s last wish to take her secrets to the grave?

The question of my own moral quandary continued to dog me when I returned home to Canada three weeks later,  becoming the subtext for a two-page spread in the Calgary Herald last weekend.


But from some quarters, the response was biting.


My mother, Agnes Spicer, always feared going back to Russia, when she lived in Netherhill, Saskatchewan, even after the Soviet Union dissolved and long after Stalin was dead and buried. In particular, she worried  how her sister, Nela’s husband, Kostantin, a highly decorated war hero, would judge her.


My mom, the POW branded as a traitor by Stalin, along with 2 million other Red Army soldiers who’d been captured by the Nazis during the War.  Kostantin Arhipov: War Hero. Defender of the Motherland. Patriot fighter who lost his leg to a Nazi land mine during the 900-day siege of Leningrad.


In the end, my mother’s fears were completely unfounded.“Kostya” (the affectionate form of Konstantin) embraced her warmly, and, in fact, became her confidante, for hours of  private conversation out on the balcony as the rest of us slept during those magical 21 days in Chusovoy in 1992, not even a full year after the breakup of the Soviet Union.

detail_nela's_mailboxEven Nela would be left out of the midnight conversations, as the two old war compatriots exchanged their stories from the Front.


He described to her how he’d used his own army knife on the battlefield outside Leningrad to dig out white larvae that grew in the open, festering leg wound, ripe with gangrene.  What my mother told him in return, only the walls of the balcony, will ever know, I fear. But perhaps, an anecdote, a detail still remains in tact in the memory banks of my octogenarian aunt.

probing _intimate_living-room

 My 89-year old Aunt Nela is my best chance for a first person glimpse into those war years that splintered the family forever. I have waited twenty years for the chance to ask her directly. My heart is beating hard. When the moment finally comes, she stops me in my tracks with a single, searing question: “Did you ever think why your mother never wanted you to know?”

It was as though the ghost of my mother was speaking to me directly, through the eyes and words of her sole surviving sibling.

“Just exactly what kind of a film are you making?” she asks, and then, a coup de grâce:

“I am sure, she would not approve.”




  1. Susan Penner

    I think that by asking you to leave the past alone, your mother was trying to protect you. She lived through those terrible times but didn’t want to burden you with them. She wanted a happy and carefree life for you. But children are tougher and more resilient than parents realize. We want to know the truth. You may feel you are bringing some justice to your mother. You are honouring her by telling the world – this is what she lived through and she survived.

  2. Thank you for helping me come a little closer to an understanding that still remains elusive…esp. returning from the first film shoot with her Russian sister, now almost 90, and against the revealing of any family secrets.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>